• News
  • Media Monitoring
  • Elections
  • Disinformation
  • Quality journalism
  • Minorities
  • Consultancy
  • Regulations
  • Newsletters
  • Blog
  •  
  • About Us
  •  
memo98

WAR ON UKRAINE - Media Insights #5

30 May - 5 June 2022

12.06.2022
 
Media Monitoring Press News Disinformation


Between 30 May and 5 June we have monitored Russian state media to detect their main war & propaganda narratives, as well as the independent international media to assess their coverage of the Russian war in Ukraine and anti-war/peace protests.

Between May and October 2022, we will be issuing a weekly newsletter containing the results of our monitoring, looking at the main propaganda narratives detected on Russian media during the week. This will be complemented by news from independent international media sources to distribute these insights outside the country. The newsletter will include main spotlights from Russian and international news coverage focusing on relevant information, key propaganda and disinformation narratives, statistics, quotes, interviews, expert opinions, independent views, as well as other pertinent developments. This is the fifth issue of the newsletter covering the period 30 May-5 June. All previous issues (since the beginning of monitoring on 4 May) can be found on our website.

You can subscribe to the public newsletter Media Insights – War on Ukraine here.


Main Events and Updates 

Between 30 May – 5 June, the monitored Russian media reported on:

  • Ukrainians shelling Donetsk as never before. “Crimes” of the Ukrainian Army (shelling of civilians, bad treatment of civilians) vis-à-vis aid to the “liberated” cities (such as Severodonetsk). This narrative is ongoing and is probably the most popular weekly topic;
  • The supply of modern US artillery to Ukraine will only bring Ukraine more suffering. In addition, foreign mercenaries in the Ukrainian Army were killed in large numbers. Russian missiles allegedly destroyed T-72 tanks and armored vehicles supplied to Ukraine by eastern European countries on Kyiv's outskirts (not confirmed by independent reporters);
  • The intermediate tribunal for Azov fighters with international representatives;
  • The looming possible fierce escalation between Russia and NATO block;
  • Russian media compared the EU summit's goals with Nazi Germany, stating that “Hitler was importing black soil from Ukraine, and today’s EU leaders dream of robbing Ukraine by taking its grain”;
  • The global food crisis wasexacerbated by Ukraine, the EU, and the US, who together mined the Black Sea ports.
  • Putin’s telephone conversations with Macron, Scholz, and Erdogan;
  • Fatigue from Ukrainian refugees across Europe, accusing refugees of being lazy and criminal.

In the same period, international media coverage of the war focused on:

  • Adoption of the long-awaited partial embargo for Russian oil exports, the 9-billion aid package for Ukraine, and ejection of Sberbank (Russia’s biggest bank), from SWIFT at the EU Summit on 30-31 May;
  • The decision by the USA to supply medium-range mobile artillery to Ukraine as a part of a new $700 million aid package;
  • The op-ed by US President Joe Biden for the New York Times and its messages, particularly, that the USA would not pressure Ukraine for any concession of territories and there is no intention to seek a war between Russia and NATO;
  • The 100-day mark of the war in Ukraine on Friday and the huge losses suffered by Ukraine;
  • Intense fighting in Donbas, especially around the key town of Sievierodonetsk;
  • Russia's cruise missiles that attacked Kyiv;
  • Putin threatening the West with retaliation if long-range multiple rocket systems are shipped;
  • Ports blockaded by Russians and the global food crisis;
  • The news that the US will send a modern rocket system to Ukraine (MLRs and HIMARS);
  • Fighting in Severodontesk and Donbas where Ukrainians are outnumbered and under-equipped;
  • The GLOBSEC forum in Bratislava.

Photos of the Week

            

A wooden hermitage (church) of the saints in Svyatogorska Lavra is on fire (Twitter account of Ukrainian mission to the OSCE).



In Russia, the first sentence was passed for "fake news" about the war. For two messages in the chat, the court imposed a fine of one million rubles (2 June, Medusa).

Quotes of the Week

"In general, all this fuss about additional arms supplies, in my opinion, has only one goal - to prolong the armed conflict as long as possible," Putin said in an interview. (5 June, Meduza)

“We do not seek a war between NATO and Russia. As much as I disagree with Mr. Putin and find his actions an outrage, the United States will not try to bring about his ouster in Moscow”, US President Joe Biden in his Opinion for New York Times. (31 May, NYT)

“Putin mustn't achieve his goals. He mustn't get away with this military onslaught against another country. This is imperialism, which we in Europe won't accept", Olaf Scholz during his address to the lower chamber of Bundestag. (1 June, Deutsche Welle [DW])

“The scale of destruction in cities defies comprehension,” said the director-general of the International Committee of the Red Cross, Robert Mardini (3 June, NYT)

Media Insights

What were the main narratives on Russian state media?

Main TV talk-shows

  • Olga Skabeeva opened her morning show by declaring that the special military operation in Ukraine had ended and a de-facto WWIII had started:
    “Perhaps it is time to recognize, perhaps, that Russia's special operation in Ukraine is over in the sense that a very real war has begun, and a World War III war. We are forced to demilitarize not just Ukraine, but the entire North Atlantic Alliance," she said. Further in the program, Skabeeva also said: “Russia is encircled by enemies; we have not yet figured out how to act without the launch of a nuclear strike.”

  • Soldiers of the Russian Army, together with special forces of the Chechen Republic and the LNR People's Militia, achieved a major success by liberating the strategically important city of Severodonetsk. Its residential area is 100% controlled by Russians;

  • Skabeeva: “Local people already celebrate and greet our soldiers as liberators!”

  • “The front is moving inexorably, and the superiority of our forces is obvious. Perhaps it’s time for Russia to install something in Cuba or Venezuela”, Olga Skabeeva summarized in 60 minutes;

  • Ukraine compensates for its losses on the battlefield by targeting civilians and residential areas:
    • Ukrainian Military Forces shelled and destroyed School #22 in central Donetsk where six people died. Today, the Ukrainian artillery shoots as if they were crazy and hysterical, much worse than in 2014 or 2015.
    • They shelled with Grads (multiple launch rocket systems) Budenovsky district of Donetsk. This is a residential area that has not been shelled since 2014. Twenty people died, including a one-year-old child. They are terrorists. No negotiations could be held with terrorists;
  • Ukrainian airborne troops recorded an appeal to Zelensky that they needed thermal imagers, walkie-talkies, power banks, binoculars, optical sights, etc. There are more and more of such appeals every day. Ukrainian TV cut short Ukrainian MP Serhiy Rakhmanin, when he spoke live about the problems of the Ukrainian military;

  • Weapons that are not destroyed by the Russian Army are stolen by Ukrainians. In Odessa, one man sold arms for 700 000 UAH. Europol is concerned about what will happen to weapons in Ukraine after the military operation is over. They want to prevent a situation of 30 years ago where criminal gangs got ahold of the military arms and use them to this today;

  • Importers agreed to pay in rubles. The ruble’s stronghold and resilience allow the Russian economy to counter Western sanctions. Prices increase for gas compensated for losses from sanctions.

  • “The West anticipated the crush of the Russian economy, but in Washington D.C., they forgot that Russians do not give up, including the ruble… Our old friend Donald Trump said that the ruble got stronger to its highest historical maximum”.  In a video from a rally Trump said: “This would have never started if I was President. It’s horror there, and there could be no winners … Under Bush, they lost Georgia, under Obama, they lost Crimea, and under Trump, they lost nothing!“; Perhaps it’s not that bad for us that Trump wasn’t re-elected”, Skabeeva concluded;

  • The anchor of the show, Olga Skabeeva commented on a recent telephone conversation between Putin and western presidents:
    “Macron and Scholz asked to free all Nazis and send them to Kyiv. It’s really strange that the German Chancellor asked to free the Nazis. They also asked to help to bring the grain out of the Ukrainian ports; the EU even considered a military operation – to send a military fleet to Ukraine. They want to rob Ukraine of every last grain.”

      (30 May, Russia 1/Smotrim – 60 minutes)

      Anti-Western Sentiments

      "It's not about Ukraine." The West leaves Russia no choice (1 June, RIA Novosti [RIA])
      [NOTE]: Very controversial piece, no authorship. Stretched and twisted facts, contradictory conclusions and a mixture of different conspiracy theories of western countries including Ukraine against Russia.

      Medvedev threatened Kyiv with strikes on decision-making centres
      In his speech, Medvedev actively pushed the thesis that Ukraine is ruled from the outside.
      “Russia will target the decision-making centres in Kyiv if authorities decide to use the weapons received from the United States against Russia”, said Deputy Chairman of the Security Council, Dmitry Medvedev. According to him, Moscow will have no other choice if the country's territory is attacked. Medvedev stressed that a blow to kill would be inflicted on key centres of the Ukrainian authorities, including the Ministry of Defense and the General Staff of Ukraine. “But you need to understand that the final decision-making centres in this case, unfortunately, are not even located on the territory of Kyiv. Therefore, this is, of course, a threat that will need to be taken into account,” the deputy head of the Security Council of the Russian Federation emphasized. (2 June, Argumenty I Fakty [AiF])

      The West has forbidden Ukraine to continue talks with Russia, Lavrov said
      In Lavrov’s opinion, the United States and Great Britain are using Ukraine as a bargaining chip. The two countries have formed an ‘Anglo-Saxon collective’, led by the West, to which NATO and the European Union, which has lost its independence, are completely subordinate. "They run the Ukrainians as a tool to deplete and defeat Russia on the battlefield," Lavrov stressed, adding that European diplomacy chief Josep Borrell, British Prime Minister Boris Johnson, and some politicians in the United States are also talking about this. (4 June, RIA)

      On Russian Special Military Operation, its advances and Ukrainian retreats

      Hackers confirmed that Kyiv was preparing an attack on Crimea and Donbass
      Russian hackers from the RaHDIt group have confirmed that Kyiv was preparing to attack the Donetsk and Luhansk People's Republics and Crimea, RIA Novosti reports. According to one of the hackers, in early February, the 72nd Center for Information and Psychological Operations, located near Kyiv, received three crews with Javelin anti-tank systems in armored vehicles. (2 June, AiF)

      Putin claimed the destruction of Ukrainian weapons by dozens
      The Russian president, in the interview during the program ‘Moscow. Kremlin. Putin.’ commented on the U.S. head's decision to send new weapons to Kyiv and assessed the effectiveness of Russian air defense: "Our air defense systems are snapping them like nuts. Destroyed dozens of them!" (4 June, Rossiskaya Gazeta [RG])

      "The number of disgruntled people is growing”. Is another coup d'etat looming in Ukraine?
      The Ukrainian media is increasingly reporting on the disastrous situation of the Ukrainian Armed Forces in Donbas. Soldiers complain about the lack of ammunition, huge losses, and the superior firepower of the Russian Army. Against this background, the unity of the country's political elite is crumbling. See RIA Novosti for a story about how Vladimir Zelensky is trying to retain power. (4 June, RIA)

      Ukrainian formations are retreating and taking out their anger on civilians
      About two and a half hundred shells, mortar shells, and Grad rockets were fired by Ukrainian formations at 15 populated areas of the Donetsk People's Republic.  One civilian was killed, five were wounded, and almost 80 residential buildings were damaged in just one day. And  in the latest news,  Donetsk has been left without television coverage. The city has never known fire of this intensity, and there's more to compare than in eight years. Ukrainian troops, having received long-range artillery from the United States, are now also waiting for American heavy drones, as well as systems similar to Grad, the range of which is a cause for separate concern. Vladimir Putin has said that Russia will not ignore these deliveries.  (5 June, First Channel)  

      On nationalism and Azov fighters

      The West continues to ignore nationalism in Ukraine (5 June, First Channel)

      • Surrendered Azov fighters with tattoos are mixed with Hitler’s Nazi parades in the video story;
      • Ukrainian nationalists found out that there are fewer Ukrainians than Russians in Ukraine;
      • Russophobia became state philosophy under Yuschenko's presidency;
      • Footage from concentration camps of Nazi Germany is shown, and a voice-over declares that Eichmann said that to kill a nation, you need to kill children first because if you kill parents, children grow up and will kill in revenge, but if you kill children, there will be no one…
      • They [neo-Nazis] succeeded in turning Russian people into anti-Russian;
      • Neo-Nazis are very good at zombifying their children. Some of them went through Maidan and now, with their hate, resist the Russian Army;
      • De-russification resulted in a collapse of education and literacy in Ukraine, and there is a generation of non-literates who can speak neither Russian nor Ukrainian;
      • The West grew Hitler, but there was a glitch when he first attacked European countries and only later the Soviet Union.

      An intermediate tribunal over Ukrainian militants will be held in Mariupol
      An interim tribunal over Ukrainian militants may be held in Mariupol, Elena Shishkina, chairman of the committee on criminal and administrative legislation of the People's Council of the Donetsk People's Republic, told RIA Novosti. According to a representative of the republican parliament, the process will not be tied to national legislation. Representatives of European countries may also be called to the tribunal, but which ones have not yet been specified. (2 June, RIA) 

      Zelensky is a “psycho” and will capitulate in September

      Zelensky has psychological problems, - László Kovér
      According to the speaker of the Hungarian parliament, László Kovér, Zelensky has psychological problems as he dared to “threaten” Hungarian leaders and even Olaf Scholz. (5 June, Russia 24)

      Zelensky will capitulate on September 17 and flee to Lithuania
      Zelensky will capitulate on September 17 and will flee to Lithuania,  predicted the 86-old former KGB officer with paranormal abilities. Russian TV called him “Ded Vanga” (Grandfather Vanga), referring to the famous Bulgarian fortune-teller Vanga. The NTV report seems to take these predictions quite seriously. (5 June, NTV)

      On consequences of sanctions – for Europe, global food crisis and influx of migrants

      Lavrov: many Europeans are threatened with poverty because of sanctions against Russia
      Many residents of European countries are threatened with poverty because of anti-Russian sanctions. This was stated by Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov in an interview with the Bosnian-Serbian television and radio company Radio-Television Republika Srpska. Tens of billions of dollars and euros go to Ukraine's armament, Lavrov continued. He recalled that German authorities decided to allocate $100 billion to militarize their country instead of supporting their citizens at a time of rising prices. (4 June, AiF)

      Lack of international support for Ukraine and fatigue from Ukrainian refugees

      Ukrainian refugees are expelled from hotels in Bulgaria and beat taxi drivers in Wien
      Ukrainian refugees are expelled from hotels in Bulgaria but refuse to go to the specialized refugee camps, reports Russia 24. Allegedly the Ukrainian war refugees are often called now in Europe “бешенцы” - a word that sounds similar to the Russian word for refugees, “беженцы”, but means frantic, mad. The report also calls the displaced people beggars, spongers and pseudo-sufferers who think that everyone owes them help. It is also reported that Ukrainian refugees have beaten a taxi driver at the center of Wien.

      [NOTE] The report about this incident was presented on RT, and while seen in other sources, there it was said that the Ukrainian identity of the attackers is still to be confirmed (30 May, Russia 24). As usual, Russian propaganda makes a frightening concoction of unconfirmed reports and distorted information using a lot of derogatory languages.



      Ukrainian refugees became a problem for Europe
      In a similar report, Russia 24 tries to create a narrative that Ukrainian refugees are no more welcome in Europe and that they are lazy beggars and don’t like to work, preferring to fool their fellow refugees with psychological and astrological services. In Italy, the Ukrainian flags are allegedly being slowly removed from the buildings, according to a local resident.  Prague announced the closure of the refugee center from June 15 because there is no more accommodation for refugees, while Poland announced that it would not pay allowance for food and accommodation (2 June, Russia 24) 

      Other topics

      The main winner of the EU Summit is the Hungarian PM Viktor Orban
      The main winner of the two-day EU summit is the Hungarian PM Viktor Orban, who achieved “oil independence” from the European Union. Hungary has become an exception from the embargo for sea oil imports (31 May, Russia 24/Smotrim.ru)

      Ukraine deliberately freezes negotiations with Russia
      Putin’s press secretary Peskov claimed that Ukraine deliberately froze negotiations with Russia under pressure from its Western “mentors”. (3 June, Ren TV)

       

      What did independent media say about the main topics? 

      EU adopts a partial Russian oil embargo

      The European Union reached an agreement on the Russian oil embargo late Monday. The deal bans Russian oil imports arriving by sea by the end of the year (but not pipeline oil, following opposition from Hungary), which will cut off two-thirds of the bloc’s total imports and cost the Kremlin billions of dollars a year. It applies “maximum pressure on Russia to end the war,” the president of the European Council, Charles Michel, said on Twitter. According to the NYT journalists, this is the harshest economic penalty yet imposed on Russia for its invasion of Ukraine and potentially the biggest sacrifice by Europe itself. (31 May, NYT). According to European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen, the scope of the ban will be wider because Germany and Poland have volunteered to wind down their own pipeline imports by the end of this year (31 May, BBC) 

      100 days of the Ukraine war

      Despite Russia’s control over 20% of Ukraine’s territory, victory will be ours - Zelensky
      “We're defending Ukraine for 100 days already. Victory will be ours. Glory to Ukraine!”, President Zelensky pledged in his video address, marking the 100 days of the war in Ukraine (3 June, BBC).  A day earlier, Zelensky said that those Russian forces were now in control of 20% of Ukrainian territory. He said almost 125,000 sq km (48,260 sq miles) was now in Moscow's hands. (2 June, BBC)

      Media coverage of 100 days in Ukraine and Russia
      Ukrainian television covered developments under the slogan "100 Days of Fortitude". This is in stark contrast to Russian TV.  BBC emphasizes that Russian media remains mostly silent on the fact that the “special operation” in Ukraine has already lasted for 100 days. A day before, the independent website Meduza quoted sources saying that the government had ordered state media not to mention the 100 days. "Focusing on dates linked to the war may make Russians think about the objectives of the invasion and about how successful it has been," one Kremlin source reportedly told Meduza. (2 June, Meduza; 3 June, BBC)

      However, some channels, including Ren TV, quoted the words of Putin’s press secretary Peskov who said: “Many settlements have been liberated from the pro-Nazi Armed Forces of Ukraine, as well as from the nationalist elements themselves, and people have been able to begin to establish a peaceful life.” (3 June, Ren TV)

      Huge losses for Ukraine: 100 days of the war
      “Fifteen thousand dead and far more wounded. About six million refugees. Half of the businesses closed, and 4.8 million jobs were lost. More than 1.5 million people were displaced internally. At least $100 billion in damage to infrastructure”, the paper sums up the tragic war tally for Ukraine (3 June, NYT)

      “The scale of destruction in cities defies comprehension,” said the director-general of the International Committee of the Red Cross, Robert Mardini. “Homes, schools and hospitals have been destroyed, and civilians have suffered the horrors of conflict, with lives lost and families torn apart.” The UN brings, however, a higher figure of displaced persons – “14 million Ukrainians have been forced to flee their homes, the majority women and children”, said the United Nations Crisis Coordinator for Ukraine, Amin Awad on Friday. (3 June, Guardian) 

      Debunking Russian propaganda narratives

      Russian war propaganda in brief
      BBC created an informative short report, presenting the main Russian propaganda narratives regarding the war:  Russia never attacked anyone; the Russian Army retreated because it had mercy for the Russian people being held hostage in Ukraine; Russia is leading an existential war against the USA and the West, and others. The report emphasized that television is the main source of news for 70% of Russians. (3 June, BBC).



      Fact-checking: Debunking the claim that Ukrainian refugees are evicted from hotels
      According to the France 24 report, Ukrainian refugees are not “evicted” from hotels in Bulgaria as Russian media says. They are being relocated because of the start of the tourist season. The report also debunks the information that Ukrainians were banned from entering some shops in Prague. (2 June, France 24)

      Military and political support for Ukraine

      While Russian media promotes a narrative of a lack of international support for Ukraine, including the fatigue from Ukrainian refugees, the international media last week  provided many stories of the military and political support for the country, including the US breakthrough decision to supply modern mobile artillery systems and the unity of the European countries against the aggression.

      The 27 members of the European Union have come together and made a “fist” and welcome refugees without complaint
      EU countries have become very united against the Russian aggression, making a “fist”, - writes Thomas Friedman in his op-ed for New York Times.  “Maybe the most impressive thing is how many Ukrainian refugees E.U. nations have been willing to house without much complaint. There is an awareness that Ukrainian menfolk are fighting to defend them, too, so the E.U. nations can at least house their women, children and elderly.” (31 May, NYT).

      President Zuzana Čaputová of Slovakia reiterated her country's support for Ukraine
      The Slovak head of state expressed her support for Ukraine in a meeting with President Zelensky in Kyiv on Tuesday, a day after an E.U. deal to ban most Russian oil imports was reached. Slovakia is heavily dependent on Russian oil but had already indicated it was working on transitioning its supply. (31 May, NYT)

      I will not pressure the Ukrainian government — in private or public — to make any territorial concessions, Joe Biden
      In his opinion piece for New York Times, US President Joe Biden reassured Ukrainians that he would not pressure the Ukrainian government for any territorial concessions. He also emphasized that America’s goal is straightforward: We want to see a democratic, independent, sovereign and prosperous Ukraine with the means to deter and defend itself against further aggression. (31 May, NYT)

      The US will supply  medium-range mobile rocket systems that are a game-changer
      Joe Biden announced that the US would supply medium-range mobile artillery rocket systems (HIMARS) that can reach targets as far as 72 km away to Ukraine as part of a new $700 million aid package. The weapons, long requested by Ukraine, are to help strike enemy forces more precisely from a longer distance. White House officials said they agreed to provide the rockets only after gaining assurances from President Volodymyr Zelensky that the weapons would not be used to attack targets inside Russia. According to BBC correspondent Paul Adams, these rockets will be a game-changer for Ukraine in its struggle for Donbas. (1 June, BBC)

      Germany will supply modern IRIS-T air defense systems to Ukraine
      According to German Chancellor Olaf Scholz, with the help of these systems, Ukraine will be in a position "to protect an entire major city from Russian air attacks."  Germany will also supply tracking radar which is capable of detecting enemy howitzers, mortars and rocket artillery. Scholz also added: “Putin mustn't achieve his goals. He mustn't get away with this military onslaught against another country. This is imperialism, which we in Europe won't accept." (1 June, DW)

      Biden announces new rockets and munitions to Ukraine
      Writing in a New York Times op-ed, Biden said the US goal is "to see a democratic, independent, sovereign and prosperous Ukraine with the means to deter and defend itself against further aggression." The UK will give Ukraine rocket systems capable of hitting targets about 50 miles away, defense secretary says on 2 June, CNN. The move has been “coordinated closely” with the United States' decision to provide Ukraine with its High Mobility Artillery Rocket System (HIMARS) — a variant of the multiple-launch rocket systems that will be gifted by the UK, the statement added. (2 June, CNN)

      Global food crisis

      Russia is using food as a war weapon and wants to create a new wave of migration to Europe
      The African Union has warned EU leaders that Moscow’s blockade of Ukraine’s ports risks “a catastrophic scenario” of food shortages and price rises. Senegal’s president, Macky Sall, who chairs the union, said that African countries strongly depend on Russian and Ukrainian wheat. After the talks with Sall, the president of the European Council, Charles Michel, tweeted: “Russia is using food as a weapon of war. Destroying crops, blocking tonnes of grain, risking global famine.” Some EU diplomats believe Russia wants to add fuel to the fire of a global food crisis with the aim of stoking a wave of migration from the Middle East and Africa that could destabilize European countries. (31 May, Guardian)

      Putin thinks the West will blink first in the war of attrition; Russian elites say
      Russian President Vladimir Putin is digging in for a long war of attrition over Ukraine and will be relentless in trying to use economic weapons, such as a blockade of Ukrainian grain exports, to whittle away Western support for Kyiv, according to members of Russia’s economic elite. (3 June, WP)

      Russia is selling the stolen Ukrainian wheat to Africa
      The United States has warned that the Kremlin is trying to profit by selling stolen wheat from Ukraine to drought-stricken countries in Africa, some facing possible famine. NYT reports that in mid-May, the United States sent an alert to 14 countries, mostly in Africa, that Russian cargo vessels were leaving ports near Ukraine laden with what a State Department cable described as “stolen Ukrainian grain.” The cable identified by name three Russian cargo vessels it said were suspected of transporting it. (5 June, NYT)

      Putin blames the West for the international food and energy crisis
      Russian President Vladimir Putin reiterated that Moscow’s actions have nothing to do with the looming energy and food crisis in the world and again blamed the economic and financial policies of the West for creating such a scenario. (5 June, CNN)

      Media work in the occupied territories

      A French journalist killed near Severodonetsk
      A French journalist Frédéric Leclerc-Imhoff who was covering an evacuation operation for broadcaster BFMTV has been killed near the battle-hit city of Severodonetsk. Officials say he suffered a fatal wound to the neck after shrapnel pierced the armored vehicle he was travelling in. (30 May, BBC)

      Men who escaped from Kherson share their stories of being tortured by Russians
      A journalist from Kherson, Oleh Baturin, shares his story of being detained and tortured in Kherson. He was imprisoned for eight days, and four of his ribs were broken. Another protagonist, Olexander Guz, who took part in pro-Ukrainian rallies, shows pictures confirming that he was severely beaten.   However, there is not a lot of evidence, as those who manage to leave often delete all the photos and videos from their phones for fear of being stopped and detained at Russian checkpoints. (1 June, BBC)

      Politicians and experts about Ukraine and Russia

      Russia is attempting to “extinguish civilization” in Donbas, Baerbock
      During a speech to the German parliament, German Foreign Minister Annalena Baerbock said Russia intends to "depopulate and extinguish civilization" in the eastern Donbas region of Ukraine. "City by city, village by village, Russian troops are destroying them from a safe distance," she said. "First the missiles, then the warplanes with artillery, and then, when everything is flattened, the tanks roll in. (1 June, DW)

      Sooner or later, a deal with Putin must be made - Larry Elliott
      In his opinion piece, Larry Elliott, the Guardian economics editor, questioned the effectiveness of sanctions against the Russian economy, claiming that the sanctions have had the perverse effect of driving up the cost of Russia’s oil and gas exports, massively boosting its trade balance and financing its war effort. In the first four months of 2022, Putin could boast a current account surplus of $96bn (£76bn) – more than treble the figure for the same period of 2021.  According to Elliott, at Davos privately, there was concern about the economic costs of a prolonged war for Europe. As a result of the war, western economies face a period of slow or negative growth and rising inflation, while developed countries may face not stagnation but starvation. Elliott concludes that a negotiated settlement may be a way to prevent economic disaster. (2 June, Guardian)

      Ukraine must meet all the necessary standards and conditions for EU accession - von der Leyen
      European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen said that Ukraine must meet all the necessary standards and conditions for accession but called on the EU to help Ukraine achieve its goals. (3 June, Guardian)

      Russia must not be humiliated in Ukraine, says Emmanuel Macron
      Giving an interview with a group of regional newspapers in his home country, the French president said: “We must not humiliate Russia so that the day the fighting stops, we can build a way out through diplomatic channels.” (4 June, Guardian)

      Battlefield

      As Luhansk falls to the Russians, civilians are desperate to evacuate
      As Russian forces push deeper into Ukraine’s eastern Donbas region, hundreds are fleeing towns and villages every day, including areas once viewed as safe. Russian missiles and rockets are expanding their reach, striking civilian areas as far as 200 miles from the front lines. Severodonetsk and the communities that surround it are growing more desolate by the day. (31 May, WP). 

      More than 200,000 children were deported to Russia from Ukraine, Zelensky says
      Russia "forcibly removes both adults and children. This is one of Russia's most heinous war crimes. In total, more than 200,000 Ukrainian children have been deported so far. These are orphans from orphanages. And children with parents. And children separated from their families,” Zelensky said. (2 June, CNN)

      In Chernobyl’s delicate nuclear labs, Russians looted safety systems
      698 computers, 344 vehicles, 1,500 radiation dosimeters, Irreplaceable software, and almost every piece of firefighting equipment made the list of what Russia’s occupying forces stole, blew up or riddled with bullets in and around Chernobyl’s laboratories, although the list is still being compiled. (2 June, WP)

      Intense fighting in Donbas, especially around Severodonetsk
      Fighting across Donbas reached “maximum intensity,” said Col. Oleksandr Motuzyanyk, Ukraine’s defense ministry spokesman. He added, “Russian invaders shelled the entire front line, trying to hit our deep defensive positions with artillery fire.” (31 May, NYT).

      Early in the week, Russia was in control of around 70 percent of the key eastern city of Sievierodonetsk, according to the governor of the Luhansk region Serhiy Haidai. The Ukrainian troops were moving to defensive positions, while the civilians were urged to evacuate to save their lives (1 June, BBC). However, on Sunday, it was reported that Ukraine recaptured 20 percent of the territory they had lost to Russian forces. (5 June, Guadian)

      Russia launched airstrikes on Kyiv for the first time in five weeks on Sunday
      On Sunday, Russia launched airstrikes into Kyiv, claiming it had destroyed the western-supplied tanks T-72 that had been provided to Ukraine by European countries that were being stored in the buildings of a car repair business, although the claim could not immediately be verified. One person was injured as a result of the strike. (5 June, Guardian)

      Anti-war/peace protests 

      The first verdict was handed down in Russia for "fakes" about the war. The court imposed a fine of one million rubles for two chat messages
      Pyotr Mylnikov, a businessman from the Trans-Baikal settlement of Olovyannaya, is the first Russian to be sentenced under a new article on "fakes" about the war. The criminal case arose after Mylnikov published two messages about the course of the Russian invasion of Ukraine in his Vyber chat room (titled "We Live on Ruins"). On 31 May, a court found him guilty and imposed a fine of one million rubles. "Meduza" spoke with Mylnikov about what "documents" he published in the chat room, how he was treated during his arrest, and why he decided to plead guilty.(2 June, Medusa)

      Online animal picket for peace in the Instagram account of Meduza
      On the 100th day of the war, subscribers of the Instagram account Meduza arranged an online animal picket for peace and against the war in Ukraine. (4 June, Meduza)

      A demonstrator was detained in Moscow with a placard "Putin should resign" (5 June, OVD-Info)

                           

      Celebrities against the war 

      Who quits working for Putin during the war?
      A BBC report provides an overview of some top advisers to the Kremlin who quit their jobs since the beginning of the war. They include Valentin Yumashev, a Kremlin adviser who helped Vladimir Putin to become president in the 1990-s, and Arkady Dvorkovich, a former deputy PM and top economic adviser to ex-president Dmitry Medvedev. Dvorkovich condemned the war in an interview with Mother Jones magazine in mid-March. He said, “wars are the worst things one might face in life… including this war”. In mid-March, three prominent journalists resigned from state-run TV news. Channel One’s Europe correspondent Zhanna Agalakova quit, as did two senior journalists at NTV. Lilia Gildeyeva had worked for the channel as a presenter since 2006, and Vadim Glusker had been at NTV for almost 30 years. (3 June, BBC)

      Opposition journalist Aleksandr Nevzorov granted Ukrainian citizenship
      A Russian opposition journalist Aleksandr Nevzorov was granted Ukrainian citizenship for “outstanding merits” before Ukraine. Nevzorov was arrested in absentia on May 6, 2022, by the Basmanny court in Moscow. He fled Russia in March. (3 June, RBC). His YouTube channel has over 1.8 million subscribers. On this occasion, he wrote on his Telegram channel: "I take the side of the victim. And I am damn grateful to those tormented, desperate, bloodied people of Ukraine who allowed me to take my place among them.”

                                     

      Nevzorov als Ukrainischer “kozak”. Source – Nevzorov’s Telegram channel

      Boris Grebenshchikov on war, collective responsibility, letters from Ukrainians and the abolition of Russian culture
      Boris Grebenshchikov, the Russian singer and leader of the rock band Aquarium, was interviewed about current events. Here are some of the main take-aways from the interview:

      • All media in Russia lie;
      • He is convinced that the war is ongoing in Ukraine, not any special operation;
      • Receives a lot of letters from Ukraine about the tragedy of the war.
        (4 June, CurrentTime)

        [NOTE]: Grebenschekov was rather reserved during the interview, the interviewer tried hard to squeeze words out of him. In contrast, his songs are very candid.



      Here is the Russian version of the newsletter #5.

       

       
      Download

       

       

       

       

      Subscribe to our newsletter

      Stay in touch with our latest news

      Subscribe

      • News
      • Media Monitoring
      • Elections
      • Disinformation
      • Quality journalism
      • Minorities
      • Consultancy
      • Regulations
      • Blog

      © 1998-2023 MEMO 98, Štefana Králika 1/A, 841 08 Bratislava, Slovakia, memo98@memo98.sk, +421 903 581 591